Tuesday, January 12, 2010

Persepolis up to 46

My initial skeptisism about reading a graphic novel has faded! I really enjoyed the drawings and the format of the reading. It is very interesting how Satrapi used pictures and word bubbles to convey her autobiographical account of her life in a revolutionary Iran. She does a good job of accuratly describing the thoughts and actions of a young girl. Marjane, as a young girl in the book, seems very precocious; perhaps it comes from growing up in a revolutionary country. The narration actually seems fairly unbiased, because Marjane's mother and father seem to take opposite opinions on some of the more contreversial issues brought up in this reading.

I am honestly amazed that Marjane's parents allow her to be present for as many discussions as they do. It seems to me that as a 9 year old, although she should be knowledgable about her surroundings, she is only going to repeat what she hears (proven in the book) and that trait might get her into trouble. As much of a life-story as this novel is used as, there is still a great deal of actual history...I'm actually learning some new things. My favorite part of this book so far is when Marjane compares Karl Marx to God, is this maybe symbolizing something deeper to her? Could it represent her closeness to both God and to revolutionary ideas?

4 comments:

  1. I really agreed in your opinion of Marjane's discussions. Especially the discussion on torture, that one should not have been heard by a small child. You can even see the effect of it. She started to play torture games, and in the end it just overwhelmed her.
    I love the way God is pictured in this book. He looks like a really sweet Santa Claus, especially when he holds her in his arms; I can almost feel the warmth that Marjane feels.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also agree that Marji experienced some extremely maturing events through her childhood. It's sad how I can't even imagine how rough it would have been living through the revolution as she did. I'm also surprised that her parents would put her in tremendous danger by bringing her with them to protests. Although what she's informing us about is very traumatizing indeed, I'm learning so much from her life story, and I think ultimatelythis book helped to psychologically heal her in a way.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am also surprised that her parents freely discuss many adult issues at that young of an age, but it is good for her. She is more aware of what is going on around her. It is hard for her to support God and her religion as the revolution continues because her religion is restricting her independence.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hmmm..I think that Marjane's parents allowed her to listen to these discussions because they'd wanted her to know what was going on. Her parents protected her, but they didn't shelter her. In that time, it was fairly evident that Marjane's childhood was to be cut short anyway so they exposed her to these horrid things. I think her parents knew what they were doing. They wanted to be an educated woman and she was.

    ReplyDelete