My initial skeptisism about reading a graphic novel has faded! I really enjoyed the drawings and the format of the reading. It is very interesting how Satrapi used pictures and word bubbles to convey her autobiographical account of her life in a revolutionary Iran. She does a good job of accuratly describing the thoughts and actions of a young girl. Marjane, as a young girl in the book, seems very precocious; perhaps it comes from growing up in a revolutionary country. The narration actually seems fairly unbiased, because Marjane's mother and father seem to take opposite opinions on some of the more contreversial issues brought up in this reading.
I am honestly amazed that Marjane's parents allow her to be present for as many discussions as they do. It seems to me that as a 9 year old, although she should be knowledgable about her surroundings, she is only going to repeat what she hears (proven in the book) and that trait might get her into trouble. As much of a life-story as this novel is used as, there is still a great deal of actual history...I'm actually learning some new things. My favorite part of this book so far is when Marjane compares Karl Marx to God, is this maybe symbolizing something deeper to her? Could it represent her closeness to both God and to revolutionary ideas?
Tuesday, January 12, 2010
Tiger stereotypes Tiger reflection
Hutchinson did a fairly accurate job of describing the racial stereotyping present in society. In my opinion, the recent Tiger Woods scandal is less race related than Hutchinson makes it seem. As with all editorials, the are written with a certain amount of bias and the writers will always find examples to back up their opinions. This article actually reminded me a lot of the movie that we recently watched that showed the effects of race on reaction to crime. It was astounding to me that the reaction to the black hoodlums was so much more profound than it was to the white hoodlums. This skewed reaction aside, I couldn't believe when a man called the police for 3 men "getting ready to rob someone." Right, I always take a power nap right before I'm getting ready to mug someone! I can honestly say that, to me, there was nothing suspicious about those men sleeping in that car, let alone something dangerous.
As Hutchinson stated, the statistics in local crime records and in jails across the country, lean towards the black majority. This is unnerving and depressing, and I understand that most people don't even know the half of it. One thing to contradict the seeming black majority in the crime population is just the availability of the stereotype. It seems that the black stereotype for crime is just easier for people to imagine, and since the good majority of the population is lazy, it is simply easier not to change their views. This social apathy is pathetic and depressing, and as Hutchinson said, electing Barack Obama as president did some, but not enough to remedy this situation.
As Hutchinson stated, the statistics in local crime records and in jails across the country, lean towards the black majority. This is unnerving and depressing, and I understand that most people don't even know the half of it. One thing to contradict the seeming black majority in the crime population is just the availability of the stereotype. It seems that the black stereotype for crime is just easier for people to imagine, and since the good majority of the population is lazy, it is simply easier not to change their views. This social apathy is pathetic and depressing, and as Hutchinson said, electing Barack Obama as president did some, but not enough to remedy this situation.
Monday, January 11, 2010
end of Caucasia
As much as people said they didn't like the end of this book because of its abruptness, I wasn't exactly suprised. Throughout the entire book, there are mysteries mentioned and abandoned. For example, we never did discover what Sandy was doing in the basement, if she was actually being chased by the Feds, and what happened to Samantha. All of these aspects of the story were left to the reader's imagination, so i wasn't particularly suprised that the ending of the story was structured similarly. I was happy for the cliche ending, in my opinion, the whole book had been fairly depressing up to that point. Birdie spent her entire childhood searching for her father and sister, and i think it gave her a certain type of closure when she found them. I liked the reappearence of Elemeno at the end of the book - it emphasized how things were on their way back to better, simpler times. I suppose Senna was aiming to end the book both in a way we would expect and in a way we wouldn't. The growth of Birdie's character throughout the book was a lot of fun to witness, Senna does a good job of changing Birdie's voice as her personality and beliefs change.
Monday, January 4, 2010
Blog Activity: Caucasia - The trip to NYC
During Birdie/Jesse's trip to New York City, Birdie/Jesse came very close to reclaiming her former identity. When she was dancing with the kids on the street outside the museum, the difference in demeanors between Mona and Birdie/Jesse was evident. Birdie/Jesse was in her element and Mona was terrified. During this section, Birdie/Jesse realizes how much she missed her old way of life, it's almost like Birdie/Jesse prefered to live as the old Birdie had, as compared to the way she was as Jesse. The little episode with Jim and the fight, also really emphasized how much Birdie/Jesse didn't like her new life. Her statement, "I didn't want those teenagers to think i belonged with these white people in the car," showed that she was at the point speaking like she wasn't a white person. The trip to New York City seemed to be a time when both Birdie/Jesse and Sandy/Sheila, reverted back to their old personalities. Sandy/Sheila once again was an unintimidated, completely unflappable strong white woman, and Birdie/Jesse again showed the side of her that was ashamed to look white/be associated with whites.
Thursday, December 31, 2009
Caucasia up to page 187
First of all, Redbone is a complete creeper! Although it couldn't be a college lit book without some sort of creeper type persona it seems. I wonder what his significance in the book is...besides showing up and doing weird things, what is it that makes Birdie's mom so afraid of him. I realize that Birdie's mom may be into some pretty illegal things, but does that really mean that the Feds are after her? Is she truly being chased or has she just reached an entirely new level of paranoia. At this point in the book, she not only has convinced herself that she is being chased, she has convinced Birdie/Jesse as well. The descriptions of their travels made me kind of sad...Birdie/Jesse was kind of forced to grow up really quickly.
I wonder if they are going to continue to stay in their sanctuary in New Hampshire, and if so, if it is because "Sheila Goldman's" paranoia is wearing off, or if Birdie/Jesse finally discovers that there was no danger to begin with. It seems to me that Birdie/Jesse's mom is finally moving past the danger of her old life, and with it, Cole and Deck Lee. I believe that this change of heart on her part will be a big source of conflict between her and Birdie/Jesse throughout the rest of the book. Also, is Jim a Fed? Or does he just represent the start of a new life for "Sheila Goldman and her daughter Jesse." It seems that Birdie/Jesse resents him so much because she refuses to let go of her sister, and with her sister, her father and all of the promises her mother had made to her while they were running.
I wonder if they are going to continue to stay in their sanctuary in New Hampshire, and if so, if it is because "Sheila Goldman's" paranoia is wearing off, or if Birdie/Jesse finally discovers that there was no danger to begin with. It seems to me that Birdie/Jesse's mom is finally moving past the danger of her old life, and with it, Cole and Deck Lee. I believe that this change of heart on her part will be a big source of conflict between her and Birdie/Jesse throughout the rest of the book. Also, is Jim a Fed? Or does he just represent the start of a new life for "Sheila Goldman and her daughter Jesse." It seems that Birdie/Jesse resents him so much because she refuses to let go of her sister, and with her sister, her father and all of the promises her mother had made to her while they were running.
Wednesday, December 16, 2009
1st Caucasia Reading Asssignment
This book is actually ok! I had heard some varying reviews about this book and so far i am liking it a reasonable amount. The author is a good writer, she does a fantastic job of narrating this book to make it seem even slightly relatable. Cole's defense of her sister is awesome and the bond they have, i'm sure, is going to play a part later in the book. They are not just sisters, they are best friends--maybe making up for their parents' failed relationship? This book is pretty long and i am interested to see how it plays out. I feel like Birdie and Cole's mother is going to get into some kind of trouble for her "activism," whatever that may include. Also, i am really interested in seeing how Birdie and Cole progress as they grow up (assuming the book goes into that at all), i feel like the differences in their skin color will force them to grow up differently.
Wednesday, December 9, 2009
A Northern Light
Love this book! Although at first, it was kind of slow, and the flashback style was confusing, by the second reading assignment, I was so into it that I read ahead and finished the book (and apparently so did several other people in this book). This post will make no sense to anyone but our book group. To be completely honest, when I found out this book was based on a true story and was a historical fiction novel, I wasn't entirely thrilled. My (former) view on historical fiction was that it was very similar to a textbook, minus terms and dates. This work of historical fiction however, was fun to read! The main character Mattie was (believe it or not) accuratly portrayed as a teenager (take that Holden Caulfield!) Although this story took place in the early 1900s, her attitude (towards school, boys, family) was almost entirely believable. One of my favorite parts of the book actually was Mattie's words of the day! Take note Mr. Kunkle! We should do this too! Mattie and Weaver's word duels were fun to listen to and (believe it or not) I actually learned some new vocab words! On a seperate note, I have several theories about Lawton leaving. One is that he was devestated by his mothers death and couldn't stand to be around the memories anymore, the other is that he wanted to make his own life and was feeling smothered by Pa's pressure to stay on the farm. Either way, I wonder why he was included in the story if we never meet him? Maybe to add more depressing aspects to the novel? The final project should be interesting...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)