Tuesday, December 1, 2009

American Whiner

I completely agree with this wonderfully critical article. I have nothing against this book at all, in fact, i kind of enjoyed it (mostly the sarcasm) but Will's take on this American classic was incredibly refreshing. To often you just hear raves about what a fine example of american literature something is, rather that hearing both sides of the argument. The statement "Holden Caulfield slouched into American life," was incredibly appropriate in implying Holden's attitude towards life in general. It actually irritated me a little bit that Holden was constantly talking about how phony everyone else was without a thought to how he might seem to everyone else. How can you call everyone else a phony when all you do is lie? What a hypocrite! Honestly, i couldn't even tell the difference between Holden and some of his "frienemies" half the time. I was surprised that West Side Story was inspired by Holden's interesting portrayal of the american teenager. Surprised, but once i thought about it, not entirely unfounded. These harsh articles were a good end to a rather polarizing book.

2 comments:

  1. I completely agree with you.
    You make a great point, Holden is quite the hypocrite.
    He was pretty phony himself if you ask me.
    His lying really annoyed me throughout the entire book. He took some of his lies way too far.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I couldnt agree with you more. I, from the begining of the book, hated Holden and it was really refreshing to hear something other than how "Catcher in the Rye" does such a great job in depicting a typical American childhood.

    ReplyDelete